What the holder owns
On paper: a membership interest in a designated Series of SHIFT DAO LLC whose sole purpose is to "acquire, hold, and maintain in its treasury assets whose economic performance corresponds to" one named index or stock. The Series 17 agreement says "Series 17 Members are owners in the Series 17 Assets" and Art. IV.1 says "Series Members are granted treasury ownership only", with no voting, management or fiduciary rights. In practice three things break that chain. (1) The issuer's own site-wide legal notice says the opposite: "The Series tokens provide their holders with economic exposure to the value of the Series Assets; holding the Tokens does not grant dividend rights, voting power, legal title, or claims to the underlying Series Assets." (2) The executed Series agreements do not identify the token they govern - membership is obtained by holding a token "created from and constricted by the parameters defined in the Smart Contract located at an address and a blockchain to be determined" - so no published document links the SPL mint that trades on Jupiter to the Series whose treasury holds the asset; the Series 17 (S&P 500) agreement compounds this by requiring "at least one (1) TSLA Short SHFT Token". (3) What the Series is documented to hold is not the referenced equity but a daily-reset leveraged ETF share (Series 17: SPXL, Direxion Daily S&P 500 Bull 3x, ISIN US25459W8626; Series 12: Direxion Daily TSLA X2, ISIN US25460G2865), so exposure to Tesla or the S&P 500 is delivered through a third party's derivative fund. Graded as derivative for that reason; if the Series agreements' "owners in the Series Assets" language controlled and were bound to these mints, the record would move to spv-claim-redeemable.
- Governing law
- Laws of the Republic of the Marshall Islands, stated in both the Terms of Use (s.12) and each Series Operating Agreement (Art. XII.2). Recourse is narrow: after a 30-day notice period a dispute "shall be settled by arbitration administered by the International Centre for Dispute Resolution", seated in the RMI, sole arbitrator, English, final and without appeal, and "No action at law or in equity based upon any claim arising out of or related to this Agreement shall be instituted in any court of any jurisdiction". The Terms of Use separately submit website disputes to "the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of RMI". Members owe and are owed no fiduciary duty (Art. IV.3, DAO Act s.109), and under Art. VI.2 (DAO Act s.111) "no one shall have the right under the LLC Act to demand to separately inspect or copy records" of the Series. A THIRD regime exists on the same issuer's vaults-only Terms, and it differs from both of the above: arbitration is "finally settled under the Rules of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce by one or more arbitrators appointed in accordance with the said Rules", with the seat "agreed by the parties" rather than fixed in the RMI, the same RMI governing law "without regard to its conflict of law principles", and - unlike the Series agreements - an express class waiver: "You agree that any disputes will be resolved on an individual basis, and you waive any right to participate in a class action lawsuit or class-wide arbitration." So one legal entity operates three inconsistent dispute regimes: ICDR with an RMI seat and a total court bar for a Series member, ICC with a negotiable seat and a class waiver for a vaults depositor, and the exclusive jurisdiction of the RMI courts for a website user. The Series agreements contain no class or consolidation provision at all, so collective redress there is unaddressed rather than waived - though sole-arbitrator bilateral arbitration reaches the same result.
- Holder scope
- non-US persons; accredited investors
- Reviewed
- 19 Sep 2026
Evidence and exact clauses (5)
- Issuer / document assertionholderClaim
WHEREAS, Series 17 Members are owners in the Series 17 Assets and can be members of the Master DAO, and members of the Master DAO can also be members of Series 17 and other Series;
- Issuer / document assertionholderClaim
IV.1 Ownership Rights. No Voting Rights. Series Members are granted treasury ownership only. Members shall have no voting rights, management rights, or authority to participate in the control or operation of the Series
- Issuer / document assertionholderClaim
A person becomes a Member by obtaining at least one (1) TSLA Short SHFT Token, created from and constricted by the parameters defined in the Smart Contract located at an address and a blockchain to be determined (the “Token Smart Contract”).
- Issuer / document assertionholderClaim
The Series tokens provide their holders with economic exposure to the value of the Series Assets; holding the Tokens does not grant dividend rights, voting power, legal title, or claims to the underlying Series Assets.
1 additional supporting claim remain in the source register.