The holder owns the actual registered common share of the listed company — not a derivative, receipt or SPV claim.
Understand ownership →Issuer programme dossier
Opening Bell by Superstate
The holder owns the actual registered common share of the listed company — not a derivative, receipt or SPV claim.
The short answer
A redemption process is documented, but no independently observed completed redemption is recorded.
Understand redemption →Control is listed as observed powers, with no single score.
Understand issuer powers →SYSTEMATIC RECONCILIATION BREAK FOUND (2026-09-16, all four Solana equities compared): Superstate's public API circulating-supply exceeds the on-chain Token-2022 mint supply by exactly 0.1 shares on FWDI (api 7,280,819.200000 vs chain 7,280,819.100000) and on GLXY (api 13,399.282876 vs chain 13,399.182876), and matc…
Understand insolvency protection →How it works, step by step
Each numbered step cites where it comes from. Colour shows how we know it; a dashed step is not established.
Superstate Opening Bell: burn to book-entry
A conversion back to registered book-entry shares — no cash payout by design.- observed seen by our own checks — on-chain unless the source says otherwise
- documented the issuer’s or a regulator’s own words
Steps as text
- Allowlisted holder → Published burn address Holder sends the equity token to the published burn address observed Source: Observed deposit (FWDI) — 2026-09-10
- Published burn address The burn address’s owner burns it observed Source: Observed burn (FWDI) — 2026-09-10 19:42 UTC
- Superstate transfer agent → Allowlisted holder Book-entry shares are credited off-chain (not observable) documented Source: Opening Bell by Superstate dossier (redemption.rails)
- Superstate transfer agent → Outside broker A transfer authorization form plus a DRS transfer moves the shares to a broker documented Source: superstate.com — s.14.5 Share Characteristics, Transfer Restrictions paragraph
Burning equity tokens does not pay cash: value is realised by selling on a DEX or through the broker.
Opening Bell by Superstate: who is involved
Every party the dossier names, and how it relates to the programme.- documented the issuer’s or a regulator’s own words
Relations as text
- Company that issues the share itself: Forward Industries, Galaxy Digital, Exodus Movement, Solana Company documented Source: sec.gov — p. 27, Forward Industries FY2025 Form 10-K
- Runs the tokenization for it: Superstate documented Source: docs.superstate.com — docs llms-full.txt, Opening Bell (issuers) page, Trading section
- Keeps the share register: Superstate, Equity Stock Transfer documented Source: superstate.com — public FWDI asset page, Details table, value of the row 'Transfer agents' (rendered text; the watcher's HTML reader no longer keeps the embedded page payload)
- Holds the underlying: Turnkey documented Source: docs.superstate.com — docs llms-full.txt, Private Key Management section (markdown as served)
- Verifies or audits: 0xMacro documented Source: 0xmacro.com — 0xMacro 'Superstate A-7' audit, Introduction (report dated May 5th, 2025)
- Distributes or lists it: Kamino, Nasdaq documented Source: forwardindustries.com — Forward Industries / Superstate launch release, 2025-12-18
- Programme answers to: SEC documented Source: sec.gov — s.4.2.3 Representations & Warranties
- Offered to: allowlisted wallets, KYC-verified platform users documented Source: sec.gov — s.1.2 Definitions
Published claim ≠ observed reality
These are conflicts between what the issuer publishes and what we observed. Edits to RWA Sonar’s own research are not listed here.
18 Sep 2026 · warning Securities-law wording says the shares lack transfer restrictions; token movement still requires allowlisted accountsThe statements concern different layers: restrictions on the shares and eligibility controls on token accounts. A user still cannot infer permissionless token transfer from the word “unrestricted”; the account-level allowlist is operationally enforced by code.
Scope: programme-wide terminology qualification
Published claimSuperstate’s Transfer Agent and Terms of Service Agreement says the shares are not subject to transfer restrictions, wording that ordinarily addresses restrictions attached to the securities themselves.
Observed realityThe filed Digital Transfer Agency Agreement requires tokens to be held and transferred only by allowlisted wallets or pools. All four Solana equity mints use DefaultAccountState=Frozen, and the Allowlist programme must thaw an account before it can transact.
Why it matters: The statements concern different layers: restrictions on the shares and eligibility controls on token accounts. A user still cannot infer permissionless token transfer from the word “unrestricted”; the account-level allowlist is operationally enforced by code.
What resolves it: Resolved when the public terms explicitly distinguish restrictions attached to the shares from wallet-eligibility and transfer controls attached to their tokenized form.
What if a part of the chain fails?
We put 38 failure scenarios (stolen keys, custodian insolvency, a frozen token, regulator action) to this programme in the same words as every other issuer. Documented means the issuer’s or a regulator’s own words address the case; inferred is our reading of the structure.
- 27 documented
- 7 inferred
- 0 litigated
- 1 unknown
- 3 not applicable
See this programme in the failure-scenario matrix →Read every answer in the issuer panel →
What happens if…
Six of the scenarios, drawn: where the failure starts, how it reaches the holder, and what this programme’s documents say happens next.
What if… My private keys are stolen and the tokens are moved.
Opening Bell by Superstate — answer documented.- documented the issuer’s or a regulator’s own words
- scenario the scenario or generic chain, not an issuer claim
Steps as text
- Holder My private keys are stolen and the tokens are moved. scenario Source: Failure-scenario list — keys-stolen
- Holder → Tokenization provider Who could act on it: the “Transfer and control” chain scenario Source: Trust-chain list — flow: transfer
- Holder Recovery is possible but not promised. documented Source: superstate.com — §6.2 Transferability Risk
- Holder In a June 2025 letter to the SEC's Crypto Task Force Superstate said that, once your lost access and identity are confirmed, the transfer agent “can reconstitute” your tokens by burning the originals and crediting new ones (its example is a forgotten seed phrase, not theft), and Terms §6.2 mentions “recovery mechanisms” for lost or stolen tokenized shares — yet Terms §6.4 says Superstate has “no way of controlling for hacks” and puts the self-custody risk wholly on you. documented Source: superstate.com — §6.2 Transferability Risk
- Holder A thief can only receive the tokens in a KYC'd, allowlisted wallet, but reconstitution is not done for tokens held in a DeFi protocol (0xMacro audit), and Superstate's total liability is capped at the greater of the fees you paid (it charges holders none) and $100. documented Source: superstate.com — §6.2 Transferability Risk
What if… The mint, freeze or delegate authority key is compromised or lost.
Opening Bell by Superstate — answer inferred.- inferred our reading of the structure
- scenario the scenario or generic chain, not an issuer claim
Steps as text
- Token program and keys The mint, freeze or delegate authority key is compromised or lost. scenario Source: Failure-scenario list — authority-key-compromised
- Token program and keys → Holder Reaches the holder along “Transfer and control” scenario Source: Trust-chain list — flow: transfer
- Holder No document addresses key compromise, so the on-chain layout decides the exposure: each mint's authority is a single funded keypair which also holds that mint's ScaledUiAmount (split) authority, so one compromised key can mint shares no register entry backs and restate every holder's displayed balance. inferred Source: docs.superstate.com — Private Key Management (“Facilitated by Turnkey”) and the admin-functions paragraph; on-chain authorities per the dossier’s keyGovernance evidence
- Holder Freeze and forced-burn are better placed — they are signed by the Allowlist program, not a wallet — but that program is upgradeable by one unmultisigged address, which is the sharpest single point of failure. inferred Source: docs.superstate.com — Private Key Management (“Facilitated by Turnkey”) and the admin-functions paragraph; on-chain authorities per the dossier’s keyGovernance evidence
- Holder The only disclosure is that key management is “facilitated by Turnkey”; no threshold, timelock, rotation history, incident response or insurance is stated. inferred Source: docs.superstate.com — Private Key Management (“Facilitated by Turnkey”) and the admin-functions paragraph; on-chain authorities per the dossier’s keyGovernance evidence
What if… The custodian or prime broker holding the shares goes bankrupt.
Opening Bell by Superstate — answer documented.- documented the issuer’s or a regulator’s own words
- scenario the scenario or generic chain, not an issuer claim
Steps as text
- Custodian or prime broker The custodian or prime broker holding the shares goes bankrupt. scenario Source: Failure-scenario list — custodian-insolvency
- Custodian or prime broker → Holder Reaches the holder along “Ownership of the underlying” scenario Source: Trust-chain list — flow: ownership
- Holder No custodian holds these shares: the token sits in your own allowlisted wallet and the share in your own name on the transfer agents' books, with Turnkey holding only Superstate's admin keys — so there is no custodian estate to be swept into. documented Source: superstate.com — §6.5 Self Custodial Activity
- Holder The price of that is the absence of a safety net: “If you do not hold your securities through a broker-dealer you will not be afforded Securities Investor Protection Corporation (“SIPC”) insurance or other broker-dealer mandated customer protection requirements.” If you do choose a broker or custodian — the 10-K contemplates delivery to a “digital wallet or custodian” — SIPC attaches only in that case, and Superstate's view that SIPA “should attach” there is its own, untested. documented Source: superstate.com — §6.5 Self Custodial Activity
What if… The token issuer goes bankrupt.
Opening Bell by Superstate — answer documented.- documented the issuer’s or a regulator’s own words
- scenario the scenario or generic chain, not an issuer claim
Steps as text
- Token issuer The token issuer goes bankrupt. scenario Source: Failure-scenario list — issuer-insolvency
- Token issuer → Holder Reaches the holder along “Ownership of the underlying” scenario Source: Trust-chain list — flow: ownership
- Holder There is no interposed token issuer to fail — the token is the company's own registered share, so nothing is segregated and nothing needs to be. documented Source: superstate.com — §14.7 Investor Responsibilities, Disclaimers & Assumption of Liability — Issuer Default
- Holder The Terms state that if the issuer becomes insolvent “your recourse is limited to recovery from the Issuer's assets and applicable securities law remedies”: you stand exactly where every other common stockholder stands, with no separate enforcement agent, no ring-fenced asset and no timetable. documented Source: superstate.com — §14.7 Investor Responsibilities, Disclaimers & Assumption of Liability — Issuer Default
- Holder Superstate's own failure is the milder, different case (see transfer-agent-fails and provider-fails). documented Source: superstate.com — §14.7 Investor Responsibilities, Disclaimers & Assumption of Liability — Issuer Default
What if… The company is acquired or merged, for cash or for shares.
Opening Bell by Superstate — answer inferred.- inferred our reading of the structure
- scenario the scenario or generic chain, not an issuer claim
Steps as text
- Underlying company The company is acquired or merged, for cash or for shares. scenario Source: Failure-scenario list — company-acquired
- Underlying company → Holder Reaches the holder along “Corporate actions” scenario Source: Trust-chain list — flow: corporate-actions
- Holder You should receive exactly what other holders of record receive, because you are one: the same class, the same CUSIP, and “identical rights” regardless of form. inferred Source: sec.gov — p. 27 (“All issued shares, regardless of form, represent identical rights…”); DTAA Schedule B (same class and CUSIP as the listed stock)
- Holder The on-chain mechanics are entirely undocumented — nothing says how tokens are burned against cash consideration, how share-for-share consideration is re-minted or allowlisted, who pays the network fees, or what happens to tokens sitting in a DeFi protocol on the closing date — and the only corporate-action machinery in the executed agreement is the dividend and distribution instruction path. inferred Source: sec.gov — p. 27 (“All issued shares, regardless of form, represent identical rights…”); DTAA Schedule B (same class and CUSIP as the listed stock)
What if… The company is delisted or goes private.
Opening Bell by Superstate — answer inferred.- inferred our reading of the structure
- scenario the scenario or generic chain, not an issuer claim
Steps as text
- Underlying company The company is delisted or goes private. scenario Source: Failure-scenario list — company-delisted
- Underlying company → Holder Reaches the holder along “Corporate actions” scenario Source: Trust-chain list — flow: corporate-actions
- Holder The token does not terminate: nothing in any document ties it to a listing, and your claim is the share itself, so a delisting changes the exit rather than the instrument. inferred Source: sec.gov — Schedule B In-Scope Securities (Venues column: NYSE American for EXOD); no delisting, termination-on-delisting or final-valuation clause anywhere in the agreement
- Holder What it removes is the price and the exit the whole structure leans on — the token has no venue of its own, and the burn-then-DRS-then-sell route ends at a market that would no longer be there — and no document sets a final valuation, a cash-out mechanism or a timeline. inferred Source: sec.gov — Schedule B In-Scope Securities (Venues column: NYSE American for EXOD); no delisting, termination-on-delisting or final-valuation clause anywhere in the agreement
Technology + legal templates
These conclusions apply only to the exact programme and observed control recipe shown.
Current Solana assets
4 exact token addresses currently inherit this issuer-level analysis unless an asset card records an exception. Watch this issuer programme →
Legal claim and issuing chain
- Issuing entity
- Superstate Services LLC (Delaware LLC, 205 W 28th Street Floor 8, New York, NY 10001) acting as 'Digital Transfer Agent'; SEC Transfer Agent File No. 84-06972, registered under Section 17A(c)(2) of the Exchange Act. Shares are issued by the public company; Superstate mints the token representing its book-entry shares.
- Entity jurisdiction
- Delaware LLC, principal offices New York, NY, USA. Issuers are US-incorporated SEC reporting companies (Forward Industries, Inc. — Delaware/NY; Solana Company (HSDT) — Delaware; Exodus Movement, Inc. — Delaware; Galaxy Digital Inc. — Delaware).
- Governing law
- New York law (Superstate Transfer Agent & Terms of Service Agreement §12; Digital Transfer Agency Agreement §16.2). US federal securities law: Securities Act 1933 registration, Exchange Act 1934 §17A and Rules 17Ad-1 to 17Ad-21, Rule 17Ad-17 lost-shareholder rule. Disputes: mandatory arbitration in New York (JAMS for investor terms; AAA for the issuer agreement), class-action waiver.
- Regulatory status
- Fully regulated US path. The underlying security is registered common stock of an SEC-reporting, exchange-listed company (Nasdaq/NYSE American). Superstate Services LLC is an SEC-registered transfer agent (File No. 84-06972; TA-1 filed 2025-02-03, amended 2025-05-05 and 2026-03-25; EFFECT 2025-03-05; TA-2 filed 2026-03-26) operating as a co-/digital transfer agent alongside the issuer's Recordkeeping Transfer Agent (for FWDI: Equity Stock Transfer). Superstate Advisers LLC is a separate SEC-registered investment adviser (funds business, not Opening Bell). No exemptive relief or no-action letter located; issuers' own filings say the application of securities laws to trading tokenized shares 'remains uncertain'.
- Holder claim
- The holder owns the actual registered common share of the listed company — not a derivative, receipt or SPV claim. The Digital Transfer Agency Agreement defines 'Tokenized Shares' as 'Issuer's Book-Entry Shares represented by digital tokens recorded on the Solana blockchain', and the holder is a holder of record in their own name (Superstate maintains name, physical address and taxpayer ID per Schedule A §3.1) — there is no Superstate nominee, street-name or custodian layer. Forward Industries' 10-K: 'All issued shares, regardless of form, represent identical rights.' Schedule B of the Exodus agreement lists the in-scope security as the same class with the same CUSIP (30209R106, NYSE American) as the listed stock; Superstate's own instrument API publishes the ordinary CUSIP for each tokenized equity.
- Underlying custodian
- None interposed. The token is the share itself, held in the investor's own name and in the investor's own wallet; the Recordkeeping Transfer Agent (Equity Stock Transfer for FWDI) maintains the issuer's Master Securityholder File and an 'On chain Eligible Shares Record' that Superstate debits/credits. Superstate maintains the 'Subsidiary Securityholder Records'. Superstate's own private-key management (for its admin keys) is via Turnkey.
Shareholder rights
| Right | For the token holder | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Dividends | Yes, as a shareholder | Paid to you as a holder of record, in cash or shares at your election; none of these companies pays one today.Source: sec.gov · Digital Transfer Agency Agreement, Schedule A s. 4.1 · “Such payment will be made in cash or additional Shares (or other agreed to form, such as stablecoins, in the future), at the election of each shareholder” |
| Voting | Yes, as a shareholder | You vote as a holder of record through proxy materials; there is no on-chain voting.Source: sec.gov · Schedule A s. 3.3 Shareholder Communication; Proxy Materials · “the Digital Transfer Agent will coordinate with the RTA to enable shareholder communication and proxy material distribution.” |
| Reports & meetings | Yes, as a shareholder | Shareholder communications and proxy materials reach you through the transfer agents.Source: sec.gov · Schedule A s. 3.3 Shareholder Communication; Proxy Materials · “enable shareholder communication and proxy material distribution.” |
| Splits | Yes, as a shareholder | Applied to your shares and shown through the token's split multiplier.Source: api.superstate.com · $.FWDI.equity_info.current_split_multiplier · “"current_split_multiplier":{"multiplier":"1"}” |
| Takeovers | Yes, as a shareholder | The token is the company's own book-entry share, so you receive what every shareholder receives.Source: sec.gov · s. 1.9 Definitions · “Tokenized Shares means Issuer’s Book-Entry Shares represented by digital tokens recorded on the Solana blockchain” |
Who can exercise token controls
Direct or one-signer control: Mint; Rebase / balance multiplier; Programme upgrade (Single upgrade key 2ccHdavxJ3eZ4aUy39sHmykFhiKkuvtomyRLRULrwkMA (Superstate admin; Turnkey-managed per Superstate, not provable on-chain)). Ultimate controller not established: Freeze accounts, Permanent delegate, Claw back / burn, Allowlist / transfer restriction.
This is the representative current exact-token recipe. Open the technology + legal templates above for recipe differences. Programme and PDA labels are traced to the effective signer where reviewed evidence permits. Thresholds apply only to the named role; initiate-only members are not counted as voters.
- Mint
- Hot key
- Freeze accounts
- Program
- Permanent delegate
- Program
- Claw back / burn
- Unknown
- Allowlist / transfer restriction
- Unknown
- Rebase / balance multiplier
- Hot key
- Programme upgrade
- Hot key · Single upgrade key 2ccHdavxJ3eZ4aUy39sHmykFhiKkuvtomyRLRULrwkMA (Superstate admin; Turnkey-managed per Superstate, not provable on-chain)
Redemption and holder eligibility
Programme-level answer. Product examples remain labelled and do not establish another token’s terms.
- Contractual right
- Yesdocumented
- Eligible holder and route
- documented
Documented at programme level. See complete terms.
Any allowlisted holder with an approved Superstate account. 'Burn to book-entry' converts tokens back to book-entry shares; those can then be DRS-transferred to a traditional brokerage and sold on Nasdaq. Available to eligible investors globally ('Global*', excluding jurisdictions subject to US sanctions); accredited-investor status is NOT required.
- KYC / AML
- Yesdocumented
- Minimum
- documented
Documented at programme level. See complete terms.
unknown
- Fees
- documented
Documented at programme level. See complete terms.
Superstate charges no processing fee for burn/transfer; the holder pays Solana network fees and any fees charged by the Recordkeeping Transfer Agent or the receiving broker-dealer (Terms §4.2, §4.3).
- Timing and settlement asset
- documented
Documented at programme level. See complete terms.
Send tokens to the published equity burn address on Solana (2u8YwJTykTreziHBN5QwE7Bi2SyN8M2MicCscthtph9E — the same burn address for all Solana equities), then the book-entry balance updates in the Superstate portal; a transfer authorization form plus a DRS transfer moves the shares to a broker. Note: burning equity tokens does NOT trigger a cash payout (unlike the funds) — you must sell on a DEX or move the shares to a broker to realise value.
- Route currently available
- Not establishedunknown
- Successful redemption independently observed
- Not establishedunknown
- Recurring on-chain scan
- Scan stale since 2026-10-10; redemptions after that date are unknown.stale
- Secondary-market exit
- Asset-specific; inspect the exact-token report for current venues and liquidity.
- Timing / SLA
- Not established
- Transfer mechanism
- program-mediated
- US persons excluded
- No
Who keeps the price honest
Programme-level answer: who can create and redeem at the issuer, so a reader knows whether a token’s premium can be arbitraged away.
Only allowlisted wallets can hold or convert it and it has no open market, so there is no price to keep honest.
- Who can create and redeem
- Allowlisted holders with a Superstate account (KYC; sanctioned countries excluded). Only allowlisted wallets can hold the token at all.
- How
- Send tokens to Superstate’s burn address and the shares reappear as book entries in its portal; a DRS transfer then moves them to a broker. Tokenizing runs the other way through the transfer agent.
- How fast
- The burn is instant; the DRS transfer to a broker takes business days; no cash payout.
- When
- Business days.
- Minimum
- None published
- Cost
- No Superstate fee; network, transfer-agent and broker fees
- Shares or cash
- Yes: you get the registered shares themselves.
- Seen on chain
- Scan stale since 2026-10-10; redemptions after that date are unknown.
Read on 2026-09-30 from the issuer’s redemption terms; the terms and their sources are under Can a holder redeem?.
Backing, custody and insolvency
- Collateral ratio
- 1:1
- Composition
- shares
- Rehypothecation
- undisclosed
- Bankruptcy remote
- Yes
- Security interest
- No
- Verification type
- transfer-agent-register
- Verification agent
- Superstate Services LLC (SEC-registered digital transfer agent, File No. 84-06972) in coordination with the issuer's Recordkeeping Transfer Agent (Equity Stock Transfer for FWDI)
- Verification frequency
- continuous / real-time (the on-chain mint supply is the tokenized portion of the register; the public instruments API is refreshed continuously)
- Verification notes
- SYSTEMATIC RECONCILIATION BREAK FOUND (2026-09-16, all four Solana equities compared): Superstate's public API circulating-supply exceeds the on-chain Token-2022 mint supply by exactly 0.1 shares on FWDI (api 7,280,819.200000 vs chain 7,280,819.100000) and on GLXY (api 13,399.282876 vs chain 13,399.182876), and matches exactly on EXOD (60.000000) and HSDT (0). The +0.1 appears on precisely the two tickers with a DeFi integration, and the FWDI asset page exposes an 'AdminSeed-Kamino-SolMainnet-900' position worth 0.607498 notional = 0.1 share at $6.07 — and the chain shows why: the 0.1 is Kamino's reserve seed deposit, a real minted token sitting in the Kamino reserve vault with no depositor claim against it (the reserve's collateral accounting counts 3,156,493.1 FWDI of liquidity while only 3,156,493.0 cTokens are outstanding; GLXY 0.583714 against 0.483714). Superstate's labels count it twice — inside 'Defi_Kamino' (which equals the vault balance, seed included) and again as 'AdminSeed-Kamino' — so the API figure is a double count, not a share without a token. Superstate's own rendered FWDI asset page shows 7,280,819.10 on Solana, agreeing with the chain and disagreeing with its own API. Economically trivial (~$0.61) but structurally the point: the chain is a mirror of the register, the mirror is measurably and repeatably off, two Superstate surfaces disagree with each other, and no published reconciliation would have caught it. There are FOUR machine-readable verification surfaces, all public and unauthenticated: (1) https://api.superstate.com/v2/instruments returns, per ticker, the CUSIP, the per-chain mint address, total_supply, circulating_supply, the equity burn address and the split multiplier — verified 2026-09-16: FWDI total_supply 8,723,436.10 , circulating (tokenized) 7,280,819.20; (2) per-ticker scalar endpoints https://api.superstate.com/v1/instruments/FWDI/total-supply and /circulating-supply (plain numbers, no auth); (3) the Token-2022 mint itself via getTokenSupply — FWDI 7,280,819.100000 at slot 447531447; (4) the Allowlist program HFkKyweJDUuGer5KaCst5qZSYD5aapKaD7xzdNaoRtfA is publicly enumerable — getProgramAccounts returned 827 accounts (698 of 32 bytes, 129 of 64 bytes) on 2026-09-16, and Superstate publishes a Rust SDK (crates.io superstate-allowlist-interface) and TS SDK (@superstateinc/allowlist) to read its state. 481 Token-2022 accounts exist for the FWDI mint. What is NOT public: the register itself (holder identities, name/address/TIN), which sits in Superstate's Subsidiary Securityholder Records and the RTA's Master Securityholder File. Superstate's /v1/balances and /v2/transactions APIs require an API key scoped to your own entity; the issuer sees a private 'Issuance dashboard'. No auditor attestation, no Chainlink Proof-of-Reserve and no reconciliation report on the equities is published. Reserve-style verification is structurally unnecessary — the token is the share, not a claim on a reserve.
Corporate actions and economics
Fees, who gets paid and long-term incentives → · Initial programme research; coverage gaps are marked.
- Corporate actions
- Dividends: on Board declaration the issuer instructs the RTA with declaration/ex/record/payment dates and amount per share; payment is 'in cash or additional Shares (or other agreed to form, such as stablecoins, in the future), at the election of each shareholder' and Superstate coordinates with the RTA to process dividends, payments and tax forms (Digital Transfer Agency Agreement Schedule A §4). Note that FWDI, GLXY, EXOD and HSDT do not currently pay dividends, so the pathway is untested in practice. Voting/proxy: the tokenized holder is a holder of record, and Superstate 'will coordinate with the RTA to enable shareholder communication and proxy material distribution' (Schedule A §3.3); there is no on-chain voting. Splits: applied at the mint via the Token-2022 ScaledUiAmount multiplier, and exposed publicly as equity_info.current_split_multiplier in the instruments API. Lost shareholders: Superstate performs Rule 17Ad-17 services; escheat stays with the issuer/RTA (Schedule A §5).
- Pricing
- reference market: exchange-nbbo · arbitrageable: true · notes: The underlying class trades on Nasdaq, so an exchange price exists, but the TOKEN has no exchange venue. Forward Industries' own 10-K warns that 'there are no current trading venues for the tokenized shares' and holders 'may face potential illiquidity, trading volatility and/or pricing discrepancies when compared to shares of common stock which trade on Nasdaq. These discrepancies may be substantial.' Arbitrage exists but is slow and one-way-ish: conversion of tokens back to Nasdaq-tradeable book-entry shares 'could take up to multiple weeks' (10-K), which is far too slow to hold the peg intraday. Solana Company's 10-K makes the same point: 'prolonged price discrepancies between Tokenized and Traditional HSDT — especially where arbitrage is limited by operational or regulatory constraints.' Superstate publishes two Pyth feeds per equity: a Nasdaq feed (Equity.US.FWDI/USD) and a Superstate index feed used by DeFi protocols (Crypto.Index.FWDI/USD); the Direct Issuance Program prices new shares off a Pyth oracle at or below the Nasdaq/NYSE price with a configured discount, circuit breakers and slippage bounds.
Primary documents and evidence
- Digital Transfer Agency Agreement, Exodus Movement, Inc. / Superstate Services LLC, dated 2025-08-08 (EX-10.7 to EXOD 10-K) — THE definitive primary document
- Superstate Services LLC Transfer Agent and Terms of Service Agreement (Sept 2025), SEC TA File No. 84-06972
- Forward Industries 10-K FY2025 (filed 2025-12-11) — 'Our shares of common stock are available in tokenized form on the Solana blockchain' risk factor and 'Tokenization of Common Stock' note
- Solana Company (HSDT) 10-K FY2025 (filed 2026-03-31) — Digital Transfer Agency Agreement dated 2025-10-17, Tokenized HSDT risk factors
- Galaxy Digital 8-K EX-99.1, 2025-09-03 — 'Galaxy and Superstate Launch GLXY Tokenized Public Shares on Solana'; publishes the GLXY mint address
- Superstate Services LLC SEC transfer-agent registration filings (TA-1 2025-02-03, EFFECT 2025-03-05, TA-1/A 2025-05-05, TA-1/A 2026-03-25, TA-2 2026-03-26), CIK 0002054806
- Superstate docs — Smart contracts (SVM contract addresses, Token-2022 extension list, Allowlist design, SDK links, audits)
- Superstate docs — Tokenized equities (allowlist, transferring/tokenizing existing shares, DeFi, burn to book-entry)
- Superstate docs — Opening Bell (issuer onboarding, tokenizing, trading, tracking, Direct Issuance)
- Superstate docs — Direct Issuance Program (architecture, EquityToken/DIP contracts, buyTheDip, KYC providers)
- Superstate docs — Onboarding API (POST /v1/accounts/onboard/svm/add-allowlist; partners submit KYC-verified data to be added to the on-chain allowlist)
- Public, unauthenticated instruments feed — CUSIP, per-chain mint, total/circulating supply, burn address, split multiplier
- Superstate Allowlist audit — 0xMacro superstate-7
- Forward Industries / Superstate launch release, 2025-12-18 — 'not representations, they are Forward Industries' Class A Common Stock'; ex-US holders only for Kamino collateral
- FWDI public asset page — live token/book-entry split and DeFi holdings
- Superstate letter to the SEC Crypto Task Force, 2025-06-17, 'Digital Transfer Agent -- Moving Securities and Markets from Analog to Digital' — the only place the token-loss reconstitution mechanism is described (§II.f: the digital transfer agent burns the original tokens and credits new ones once lost access and identity are confirmed, modelled on UCC 8-405 at its footnote 38), and the only place Superstate states its own view that Securities Investor Protection Act protections 'should attach' — but only to a broker holding on the investor's behalf (footnote 36, citing 15 U.S.C. 78aaa), i.e. never to a self-custodied holder
- Superstate written input to the SEC Crypto Task Force, 2026-07-31, 'Tokenization; Project Crypto at One' — Superstate's own reading of what the staff has conceded: 'a transfer agent may use a blockchain as its official master securityholder file without keeping a duplicate "digital twin" off-chain', which is the premise that makes the on-chain register authoritative rather than a mirror
- SEC Division of Trading and Markets FAQ, Crypto Asset Activities and Distributed Ledger Technology — Q11 is the regulator's own statement of that position: a registered transfer agent may use DLT as its official Master Securityholder File under Exchange Act Rule 17Ad-9(b) and 'would not need to maintain a duplicate or "digital twin" of its master securityholder file exclusively off-chain', provided the records stay secure, accurate, current and producible to regulators
Open research questions (11)
- Is the FWDI/HSDT Solana equity token program the same code as the audited Superstate token programs, and has the EQUITY-specific program (and the EVM EquityToken/DIP contracts) had an independent security audit? The published 0xMacro/ChainSecurity audits cover USTB/USCC and the Allowlist; no equity-token audit was located.
- Governance of the admin keys. The Solana Allowlist upgrade authority (2ccHdavxJ3eZ4aUy39sHmykFhiKkuvtomyRLRULrwkMA) and each mint authority are on-curve, system-owned addresses with no multisig program account. Turnkey may enforce an off-chain N-of-M policy, but no threshold, quorum or timelock is disclosed anywhere. Single-key compromise would reach mint, freeze, forced-burn and allowlist writes.
- Which register wins in a dispute? The DTAA makes the RTA's off-chain Master Securityholder File authoritative and Superstate's record 'subsidiary', while the SEC-filed Galaxy 8-K says Superstate 'records legal ownership onchain in real time' and 'the registered shareholder list of Galaxy updates in real-time'. If the chain and the RTA's file disagree, no document located says which controls, or who bears the loss.
- RESOLVED for FWDI and EXOD, open for the rest: FWDI's published CUSIP 349862409 is the ordinary Nasdaq-listed common-stock CUSIP, assigned by Nasdaq when the 1-for-10 reverse split took effect 2024-06-18 (nasdaqtrader.com Equity Corporate Actions Alert #2024-287) — so no separate tokenized tranche. EXOD's 30209R106 is confirmed by Schedule B of the signed agreement. GLXY (36317J209), HSDT (42328V876) and SBET (820014405) were taken from Superstate's own API and not cross-checked against an independent CUSIP source.
- Is there a dividend precedent? DTAA Schedule A §4 sets out a full cash/shares/(future stablecoin) dividend path, but FWDI, GLXY, EXOD and HSDT do not pay dividends, so the path has never been exercised. Likewise no split has occurred (multiplier still 1), so the ScaledUiAmount corporate-action mechanism is untested in production.
- Has proxy voting actually been exercised by a tokenized holder? Schedule A §3.3 only commits Superstate to 'coordinate with the RTA to enable shareholder communication and proxy material distribution' — no record of a tokenized holder voting at a meeting was found.
- Why is HSDT (Solana Company) still at zero supply? The token was deployed 2025-11-14 and the Digital Transfer Agency Agreement is dated 2025-10-17, but the mint supply was 0 on 2026-09-16. Announced but effectively not live; treat HSDT as non-operational for grading.
- What is the real ownership dispersion? 481 Token-2022 accounts exist for the FWDI mint, but ~43% of tokenized supply (3,156,493 FWDI, $19.2M) sits in Kamino, and the public asset page shows an 'AdminSeed-Kamino' label — so the holder count overstates independent economic holders. ANSWERED (2026-09-23): six wallets, not 481. Only five FWDI token accounts hold a non-zero balance (getTokenLargestAccounts, slot 449684185): four ordinary system-owned wallets outside Kamino (ANpjx… 3,513,514; 3Eob… 600,000; DeUZz… 10,811; J9mW… 1 — together 4,124,326.0, exactly Superstate's 'Token-SolMainnet-900' label) and Kamino's reserve vault GrSCwq… (3,156,493.1, owner the Kamino lending-market authority 8ULQx…). The vault is pooled protocol custody, not a holder. Enumerating the Superstate Pool market's obligations (Kamino program KLend2g…, market CF32kn…, 13 obligations, slot 449685432) finds exactly two with FWDI deposits: obligation 67oam…, owned by E3NiM5…, with 3,134,871.0 FWDI (99.3% of the Kamino position, 43.1% of the Solana supply), and obligation fL52B…, owned by BKLBm…, with 21,622.0. The remaining 0.1 is Kamino's reserve seed, which has no cToken and no owner. So the economic holders of tokenized FWDI on Solana are at most six wallets, two of which hold 91.3%; the other 476 token accounts are empty. The chain cannot tell whether any of the six share a controller; all six are plain system-owned keypairs. The 481 count measures allowlisted accounts, not holders.
- Why is the public API's circulating-supply exactly 0.1 shares above the on-chain mint supply on FWDI and GLXY but exact on EXOD and HSDT? The 0.1 'AdminSeed-Kamino' position on the FWDI asset page is the likely cause, but nothing states whether that 0.1 is a real share in the register with no token, a display artefact, or an unminted placeholder — and no published reconciliation would reveal which. ANSWERED (2026-09-23): it is a double count in Superstate's own labels, and the share is minted. Kamino seeds each new reserve with an initial deposit for which no cToken is issued: the FWDI reserve 2ZdH2K… holds 3,156,493.1 FWDI of liquidity and counts 3,156,493.1 of collateral in its own accounting, but the cToken mint Dg65YX… has only 3,156,493.0 outstanding (slot 449684047); the GLXY reserve 4v8hN3… holds 0.583714 against 0.483714 cTokens outstanding. Superstate's 'Defi_Kamino-SolMainnet-900' label equals the vault balance, seed included (FWDI 3,156,493.1, GLXY 0.583714), and 'AdminSeed-Kamino-SolMainnet-900' adds the same 0.1 again. Without the AdminSeed label the labels reconcile exactly to the mint supply (FWDI 4,124,326.0 + 3,156,493.1 = 7,280,819.1; GLXY 13,398.599162 + 0.583714 = 13,399.182876, getTokenSupply at slots 449684114/449684116). EXOD and HSDT have no Kamino reserve, hence no seed and no gap. Re-read 2026-09-23: api.superstate.com/v2/instruments still reports FWDI circulating_supply 7280819.200000 and GLXY 13399.282876. The break is a reporting error, not a register-to-chain divergence; it still shows that nobody publishes a reconciliation that would catch it.
- RESOLVED: the freeze-authority/permanent-delegate address 2Yq4T3mPNfjtEyTxSbRjRKqLf1pwbTasuCQrWe6QpM7x is controlled by the Allowlist program, proven on-chain rather than taken from the docs. Transaction 2hYLRFwbxU7DcMxGudfJopFdCT1txbsi4eLa8zAPo47Enp8hyPhLKK6XDbdUFtuHnWFxTuBxYoN1Z3si2dSZFbDy (blockTime 1789052737, i.e. live activity on 2026-09-16) invokes the Allowlist program HFkKyweJDUuGer5KaCst5qZSYD5aapKaD7xzdNaoRtfA, whose inner instructions are Token-2022 getAccountDataSize, System createAccount, initializeImmutableOwner, initializeAccount3 and thawAccount — i.e. the program creates the associated token account with the ImmutableOwner extension and thaws it in one shot, signing as freeze authority via that PDA. Confirms the documented design and confirms ImmutableOwner is applied at the token-account level. What remains open is only the seed derivation (common single seeds did not reproduce the address) and, separately, who controls the program's upgrade authority.
- Superstate's fee to the issuer is $1 per year (DTAA §3.1). Is the commercial arrangement documented elsewhere (equity, warrants, platform fees), and does it create an incentive misalignment for a party that also holds forced-burn authority?